Making Evaluation maps


#1

Evaluation maps or site assessments are useful in designing interventions or a management strategy. in Geodesignhub, they are simple red / yellow / green maps that tell the designer locations where intervention is required and where they should be careful.

If the project participants are familiar with the study area, evaluation maps may be less useful since they can rely on their local knowledge. For large study areas, evaluations are very useful. Evaluation Maps can be created using three or five colors; using three colors could simplify things for you.

There are three ways to create evaluation maps:

  1. Sketching by hand using printed maps and red, yellow, green markers and digitizing the sketched maps directly on Geodesignhub.
  2. Using GIS software and existing data such as QGIS / ArcGIS to build these maps.
  3. Using automated tools and scripts, this is most suitable if you don’t want to build the maps. You will need basic programming knowledge so if you don’t have the resources, we can run these scripts for you and your project. They are free and opensource and use opendata. (OpenstreetMap, CORINE, Sentinel Data, NLCD etc.) :

For more information about these tools please review this PowerPoint Presentation

Additional Notes

Evaluation models can be created using the setup sheet provided since it will help in identifying data sources and building a legend for the colors. The figure below details the legend for the five columns:

All evaluation maps can be shown in a simple three or give color map: Red , yellow and green, or red, yellow, green, green2, green3.

Legend

1 (red) is where the system is “existing” already and in a healthy state, meaning that it is feasible to remain….a constraint in terms of information but not a total Constraint.

2 (yellow) is lowest priority for change… “not appropriate” or not capable of supporting the system, meaning don’t put it there, e.g too wet or steep or….unless you provide change to the basic area conditions e.g fill in the ocean for new land, regrade the mountain, etc… (all very risky projects). This is also a constraint in terms of information.

3 (green) is low but higher priority ….”capable”, meaning that you can place it here IF you also provide the technology and market to make it feasible, e.g. water and sewers, access roads for mechanical harvesting, etc., and the market comes…

4 (green2) is higher priority….”suitable”, meaning that the area is capable of supporting the project and it already has the appropriate technologies to support the activity taking place e.g. septic tank soil or sewers, access roads for mechanical harvesting, etc. BUT there may not yet be a market for the change.

5 (green3) is the highest priority for change….“feasible”, meaning that it is suitable AND there is a demand or market to provide the new land use change, e.g that someone wants to buy the product or new house (and at a profit) OR that the government wants to protect and improve an historical landscape .

These details have to be filled out by project administrators on a per system basis. Once the criteria are set, you can build five-colored Evaluation Maps using traditional GIS tools. While this process varies between different users and techniques and is specific to the study area and produce a five color map.

GIS File format

If you are going to use GIS, the files should be in Vector / Shapefile format, all rasters should be converted to vectors.

Data Attributes

Every polygon must have an attribute called “areatype” in the attribute table and it can have one of the five values:

  • red
  • yellow
  • green
  • green2
  • green3

For a more detailed information please review the feature attributes topic.

Miscellaneous

Ensure that there are no topological or geometry errors in the file and it should be re-projected to WGS 1984 / EPSG 4326 projection to be compatible with the tool.

It is recommended to remove all other values from the attribute table, and covert the shapefile to GeoJSON using a tool such as QGIS. For more information about conversion please review the Converting Shapefile to GeoJSON topic.

Sample files

Uploading evaluation maps

Once the maps are complete and built, you can upload them to your project, review the How to upload evaluation maps article.


Linking Raster Evaluation and Impact Maps